mysophobia 潔癖

Nastiness Diagnosis. Anthropology. Religion. Gender. Justice. A Personal Notepad For the General Public.

ber-Islam ala “gado-gado”

還沒開始讀「都市穆斯林女人」這本研究「街頭時尚戴頭巾者社群」的印尼贈書,但已經愛上Ahmed教授的導言。I have not read the text of Muslimah Perkotaan (which studies Community of Hijabers) by Faiz Aziz. But I already love the introduction by Ahmad Muttaqin:

**
可能嗎,我們活著的伊斯蘭就走「印尼沙拉」的風格?信條採取瓦哈比,膜拜的法學根據是漢寶禮學派,可是齋戒的方式又是跟從夏飛義學派;思考方式如同什葉派的阿里,靈心與身心卻交給納許雅龐地的蘇菲主義組織,但諷刺的是做生意時撐住的是百分之百的世俗模式。
Boleh jadi selama ini kita ber-Islam ala “gado-gado”: aqidahnya pakai Wahabi, fiqih sholatnya menggunakan Hambali namun puasanya mengikuti Syafi’i; pemikirannya terpesona oleh Ali Syariati yang Syi’i itu, spiritual dan pekertinya diolah dari Tarikat Nasqsyabandi, namun ironime bisnisnya 100% ditopang oleh ekonomi sekuler.
**


作為今晚睡前的閱讀,實在畫龍點睛。因為我今天一整天都在研究印尼宗教學者協會的宗教判決建議的方法論,深深發現雖然印尼穆斯林學者大咖都是Shafi’i的專家,200多個舊的fatawa中去大約有十成的fatwa其實是使用Maliki的「防患未然」方法。於是我必須說真的仔細探究清真判決建議書的話還真的必須case by case,並不是所有MUI發出的 fatwa都是根據Shafi’i學派的法學方法論。這也讓我體會到這真的是一個巨大的工程,我最好只慎重選擇某些案例來說明清真科學的發展的特殊性,否則根本不可能無法負荷。
另外一個領悟就是我可以閱讀文藻豐富、幽默詼諧又充滿詩意的印尼學術論文,但我自己絕對寫不出來。

This is after a whole day of trying to figure out the methodology fatwa MUI only to have a conclusion: that although most MUI scholars are shafi’i followers, they do from time to time use Maliki’s methods, and that’s why about 10% of the fatwa is like that. But of course that is already permitted within Shafi’i that under certain circumstances one can follow other schools’ opinions.
I will call it a day.

Advertisements

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Information

This entry was posted on August 1, 2017 by in 【Indonesia-ish & SEAsia】.
%d bloggers like this: